AI removes the friction. Where should students keep it?

Instant answers can skip the effort that makes learning stick. What that means for heads of department, from our Beyond the Bell panel with QSPA.
Type a Year 10 maths question into ChatGPT and you’ll get a worked solution in seconds.
Atomi co-founder Rob Barakat traced how we got here at Beyond the Bell, our evening with the Queensland Secondary Principals’ Association (QSPA).
There used to be friction where the student had to go to a book. [Then] the student had to go to YouTube to find the video that’s going to teach them the thing. Now they can just get a solution to any response in any subject instantaneously.
—Rob Barakat, Co-founder, Atomi
Each step made answers easier to reach. Rob’s concern is what students lose along the way. “The studies show that [it] doesn’t lead to great outcomes for students,” he said. “It doesn’t actually teach them very effectively.”
The hard part is where learning happens
The friction Rob described did a job. Working through a problem or recalling a method is how knowledge sticks. Psychologists Elizabeth and Robert Bjork call this desirable difficulty. Practice that feels harder in the moment often leads to better long-term learning.
A 2025 study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences shows what happens when that friction goes. In a trial with nearly 1,000 high school maths students in Turkey, researchers gave some students GPT-4 during practice. Those using a standard ChatGPT-style tutor did 48% better on practice problems than the control group. When the AI was taken away for the exam, they scored 17% worse than students who never had it. The researchers’ explanation was that students used the AI as a crutch and never built the skills themselves.
Design decides what students keep
The same study had a second group. Their AI tutor was set up to give hints rather than full answers. Those students improved even more in practice, and the drop on the exam largely disappeared.
The second result suggests the harm came from how the tool was set up, and that’s something schools can control. Rob sees the same gap in most tools reaching classrooms.
The technology doesn’t come packaged with the pedagogy most of the time.
—Rob Barakat, Co-founder, Atomi
He expects students to “gravitate towards this technology and kind of run with it”. Left alone, many will take the shortest path to an answer. Good task design stops that path from skipping the learning.
Choose where effort stays in each unit
For a head of department, the job is deciding which parts of each unit students need to work through themselves. Work through it unit by unit with your faculty.
1. Mark the tasks that need unaided effort. First attempts at new problems, retrieval practice and first drafts are where students build the skill. Keep tools that hand students the answer out of these, or limit them to hints. A tool that has students recall the answer themselves, like a quiz, keeps the effort where it belongs. Where you can, start these tasks in class and watch how students tackle them.
2. Bring tools in after an attempt. Checking an answer, getting feedback on a draft or finding where a misunderstanding started all help once students have had a go.
3. Build the use into lessons. Handing out a login leaves the benefit with students who’d find it anyway. Dr Julie Arnold, a Queensland University of Technology researcher on the panel, said the research points the same way.
[The] benefit might accrue to a kid who already has agency who will decide exactly how to use it.
—Dr Julie Arnold, Researcher, Queensland University of Technology
That gap can widen. Show students when and how to use a tool in class, so the whole class gets the benefit.
Decide where Atomi fits. Your teachers can try Atomi free with their class today and see how it fits your units. Try it free →
Pick one topic for Term 1
Plenty of AI tools will pitch for a place in your faculty next year. Before any of them gets one, take the first topic you’ll teach in 2027 and mark where the effort has to stay with students. Then judge each tool by whether it protects that effort or removes it.
Test Atomi against your own units. Book a demo and we’ll walk your faculty through Atomi, so you can judge it against the effort you want students to keep. Book a demo →
References
- Bastani, H., Bastani, O., Sungu, A., Ge, H., Kabakcı, Ö. and Mariman, R. (2025). Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning: Evidence from high school mathematics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(26).
- Bjork, E. L. and Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In Psychology and the Real World.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest teaching and learning insights delivered to your inbox.
You can unsubscribe at any time, no hard feelings.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest teaching and learning insights delivered to your inbox.
You can unsubscribe at any time, no hard feelings.
What's Atomi?
Easy to understand, super engaging, and matching what you’re learning in class. Available for 100s of subjects across your high school years.
With heaps of questions and smart AI feedback that shows you what you’ve nailed and what to work on—so you won’t just feel ready, you’ll be ready.
Improve your study game, get AI-driven tips tailored to you, keep tabs on your progress and unlock insights so you can always hit your goals.
What's Atomi?
Captivating and impactful video-first content, fit for all types of learners and grounded in the absolute must-have info of the high school curriculum.
Active recall quizzes, topic tests and exam practice enable students to get immediate feedback and build skills, while allowing teachers to differentiate instruction.
Create engaging learning experiences with easy-to-use tasks, get actionable insights to differentiate instruction and experience intelligent personalisation for your students.
What's Atomi?
Short, curriculum-specific videos and interactive content that’s easy to understand and backed by the latest research.
Active recall quizzes and practice sessions enable students to build their skills, put knowledge into practice and get feedback.
Our AI understands each student's progress and makes intelligent recommendations based on their strengths and weaknesses.
